Should baseball cleats be tight?

When playing baseball, you are always on the move. You, therefore, need the right size of cleats to enhance stability and safety.

Ensure you choose baseball cleats that are a bit tight so that your feet do not keep on moving around as you wear your favorite baseball shoes.

Buying baseball cleats can, however, be challenging since there are so many factors to consider.

You should, however, take your time since the wrong cleats can lead to issues such as discomfort or an injury.

To prevent this, we decided to come up with a comprehensive guide that can help you when buying baseball cleats.

We will discuss not only cleat sizing but also the types of cleats and other considerations to make during your purchase. Enjoy!

What is the right type of cleats to choose from?

If you are searching for a perfect shoe for your favorite game, you should focus on the cleats. They should offer a lot of flexibility for you to move around fast without the risk of injuring yourself.

Cleats are designed to offer superior traction and support. They are, however, divided into different categories and should be used in varying field conditions. The types of cleats are as follows.

  • Metal cleats

If you are playing on grass or a hard dirt surface, you can choose baseball metal cleats. These tend to dig into the surface effectively while giving you a firm grip to take off.

Most of the college athletes and professional players choose metal cleats due to the excellent traction. These are not, however, allowed in amateur leagues due to safety reasons.

Though they can easily cause an injury, metal cleats are lighter than other types, therefore increase a player’s agility.

  • Plastic cleats

Some baseball shoes come with rubber parts attached to the sole permanently. Plastic cleats often go with different surfaces without wearing out quickly.

If you are on a budget, you will find plastic cleats cost-effective. The problem with plastic cleats is that they don’t grip the ground as well as metal cleats.

That is why most people choose them for muddy or soft ground conditions since they tend to bounce off such surfaces with ease allowing you to keep on going instead of digging into the mud.

Most youth players like the durability and versatility of these cleats since they can last an entire season.

  • Turf cleats

If you are playing baseball on artificial turf, you need to choose turf cleats. These are known to be the most comfortable cleats in the market.

Though they don’t offer the same level of grip as metal or plastic cleats, they don’t wear out quickly. They are best for training since they provide excellent traction and reduce the risk of getting injured.

Should you buy tight baseball cleats?

Apart from choosing the right type of cleats for your game, you should also focus on the sizing. You should select baseball cleats that are a bit tight instead of too loose.

As you play, your shoes are likely to expand. Choosing loose cleats will, therefore, cause discomfort rather than picking tight ones.

Loose cleats can make your feet keep on moving around too much in the shoes. This can cause blisters upon regular use.

Snug-fitting shoes cling to the feet and give you the necessary support as you make movements and twists.

As you try on the baseball shoes, wear some athletic socks so that you can gauge the exact fit of the cleats. Also, confirm that the cleats have enough cushioning.

What other factors should you consider as you buy baseball shoes?

As you buy baseball cleats, you should also focus on their construction. Most baseball cleats are made of synthetic or genuine leather.

Those that are constructed with genuine leather are breathable and durable. Choosing one made of synthetic leather, on the other hand, helps you save on costs since they are cheap.

This gives you adequate support at the ankle and foot. Cleats made from synthetic materials are ideal for wet field conditions.

You also have to focus on the ankle support of baseball cleats. The option you choose has a significant impact on the stability of your ankle. You can either buy high, mid, or low cut cleats.

If you previously injured your ankle but would like to resume playing baseball, you should choose high cut cleats.

Since these extend up to your ankles, they can give you extra support during lateral movements. They, however, have more material compared to low cut cleats. This makes them a bit heavier.

Some baseball players focus on speed more than stability when choosing cleats. In this case, get low cut cleats to enhance your sprinting ability across the field.

Since these are lighter, they increase the agility of a player and don’t add any restrictions on the ankles. You can still get good ankle reinforcement with mid-tops. These enhance your movement in the field.

You should also pay attention to the stud length of your cleats. Various stud lengths work well in particular fields. If you are playing baseball on a hard surface, you should choose shorter studs.

Longer studs are designed for soft baseball fields since they can easily dig into the ground more.

Toe drag is also another crucial consideration you should make as you choose baseball cleats. If you are a pitcher, go for baseball cleats that have a reinforced toe area.

Cleats that don’t have reinforcement tend to wear out quickly after a short duration. The reinforced toe area also makes baseball cleats quite comfortable.


Before you start playing baseball, you have to do some research for you to get the right equipment for the game. One of the necessities in this game is baseball cleats.

The right size of cleats can help you remain stable as you play. Choose the ones that fit a bit tight rather than being too loose to avoid blisters.

Since your shoes must expand, snug-fitting cleats can enhance movements during your game.


My name is Don Mattingly (not the famous one) - CEO Founder MattinglyBaseball. I dedicated my whole life into baseball, I have gathered a lot of experience through all my years. I hope my blog will be useful to some people.